
Raised scars are treated by type. At IN Eternity Clinic, Dr Sin Yong tells a keloid from a hypertrophic scar, then plans injections, silicone and selected laser, with referral when surgery plus an adjuvant is the better route.
WhatsApp to Enquire →Key facts ↓A hypertrophic scar stays within the original wound and often softens over a year or two; a keloid grows beyond it and rarely settles alone. Both are usually treated first with steroid injections into the scar every four to six weeks, plus silicone gel or sheets, with laser for redness or texture once flattened. Keloid removal by excision alone often recurs, so it is combined with an adjuvant. Dr Sin Yong assesses which type you have.
Both are raised scars made of too much collagen, and both can be red, firm, itchy or tender. The difference is behaviour. A hypertrophic scar stays within the borders of the original wound, usually appears within weeks, and often flattens and pales by itself over one to two years. A keloid grows beyond the original wound into normal skin, can keep enlarging for years, rarely settles on its own, and is more likely to return after treatment.
| Feature | Hypertrophic scar | Keloid |
|---|---|---|
| Borders | Stays within the original wound | Spreads beyond it, often with claw-like edges |
| Onset | Weeks after the injury | Weeks to months, sometimes after a minor injury or a pimple |
| Course | Often softens and flattens over 12–24 months | Rarely regresses; may keep growing |
| Common sites | Anywhere under tension, across joints, after burns | Earlobes, chest, shoulders, upper back, jawline |
| Response to treatment | Usually good | Often partial; recurrence is common |
The two can overlap, and some scars behave in between. Telling them apart matters because it changes how aggressively the scar is treated, whether surgery is ever sensible, and how much maintenance to expect. The broader picture, including flat and indented scars, is in scar removal in Singapore.
Keloids and hypertrophic scars are now understood as a prolonged inflammatory response in the deeper dermis. Instead of switching off once a wound has closed, fibroblasts keep laying down collagen, signalled by growth factors and kept active by tension on the skin. The scar becomes thick, with collagen in dense swirls rather than the orderly pattern of normal skin.
In Singapore, earlobe keloids after piercing and chest or shoulder keloids after acne are the most common reasons people ask about removal. If acne is still active on the chest or back, settling it is part of preventing new keloids; see back acne treatment.

Injecting a corticosteroid directly into the scar is the usual first treatment for keloids and for hypertrophic scars that are not settling. The steroid, commonly triamcinolone (a prescription medicine), dampens the inflammation that drives collagen production and helps break down the excess. Over a series, a raised scar usually becomes flatter, softer and less itchy or painful.
Injections are given into the body of the scar with a fine needle, every four to six weeks, and the dose is adjusted at each visit to how the scar is responding. Firm keloids can be uncomfortable to inject; numbing cream and a slow technique help. Several sessions are usually needed, and a large keloid may need many.
The main side effects are local: thinning of the skin around the scar, a lighter patch, small visible vessels or a slight dip if steroid reaches the fat beneath. These are why the dose is kept to what the scar needs and why spacing matters. In some cases an anti-scarring medicine (5-fluorouracil) is combined with the steroid for scars that respond poorly. These choices are made by Dr Sin Yong at assessment.
Silicone is the most widely recommended first step for preventing raised scars and for treating early hypertrophic scars. It is thought to work by hydrating the outer layer and reducing the signals that keep fibroblasts busy. It is simple and low-risk, but it is slow and depends entirely on consistent use.

Lasers are an add-on for raised scars, not a first treatment. Vascular lasers such as pulsed-dye laser target the small vessels that keep a young scar red and active; long-pulsed 1064 nm Nd:YAG is another wavelength used for this. Fractional lasers make microscopic channels that can soften texture in mature, flattened scars and help steroid spread more evenly.
In Asian skin, lasers on scars carry a risk of post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation, and heat on an active keloid can sometimes provoke it. At IN Eternity Clinic, laser is used selectively, mainly once a scar has been flattened with injections, to improve redness or texture. A scar that is still growing is treated with injections first.
“A hypertrophic scar stays inside the wound; a keloid keeps going past it. Cutting a keloid out on its own usually invites it back.”
It can, but cutting it out on its own is one of the commonest reasons a keloid comes back. The new wound is itself an injury in keloid-prone skin, and reviews report recurrence after excision alone in roughly half or more of cases, sometimes larger than before. That is why excision is planned as one step in a combination, never as the whole treatment.
When surgery is sensible, for example for a large earlobe keloid or one that has not responded to injections, it is combined with an adjuvant to stop regrowth: steroid injections into the wound edges over the following months, pressure earrings for earlobes, silicone, and in selected cases low-dose radiotherapy given within days of surgery. Radiotherapy and complex excisions are carried out by hospital plastic surgery, dermatology or radiation oncology teams. If that is the right route for you, Dr Sin Yong will say so and arrange a referral.
Cryotherapy, freezing the keloid from outside or within, is used at some centres for small keloids. It can leave a pale patch, which is more noticeable in darker skin, so it is discussed carefully.
Raised scars respond slowly and in stages. The table gives typical roles; the actual plan depends on the scar, its age, the site and your history of keloids.
| Option | Role | Typical course | Main trade-offs |
|---|---|---|---|
| Steroid injection | First-line for keloids and stubborn hypertrophic scars | Every 4–6 weeks over several sessions | Skin thinning or lightening if overused; discomfort |
| Silicone gel or sheet | Prevention, early scars, maintenance | Daily for at least 2–3 months | Slow; depends on daily use |
| Laser | Redness and texture once flattened | A short course, spaced weeks apart | Pigment risk in darker skin |
| Excision with adjuvant | Large or resistant keloids | Surgery, then months of follow-up | High recurrence without adjuvant; referral |
| Pressure | Earlobes after excision | Worn daily for months | Comfort, compliance |
Success is measured as a scar that is flatter, softer, paler and no longer itchy or painful, not as the scar disappearing. Keloids can recur months or years later, so follow-up is part of the plan.
Most raised scars are what they appear to be. A lump that appeared without any injury, grows quickly, bleeds, ulcerates or looks different from your other scars should be examined properly, and sometimes sampled, before it is treated as a keloid, because a few skin growths can mimic one. Scars that restrict movement across a joint, or burn scars over a large area, belong with a burns or plastic surgery team. Flat, red or brown marks after acne are not raised scars at all; see acne scar treatment.
Keloids can usually be flattened and softened, but no treatment removes the tendency to form them. Excision on its own often leads to recurrence, so it is combined with injections, pressure, silicone or radiotherapy. Follow-up continues because keloids can return months or years later.
It varies with size and age. Small, young keloids may flatten after a few sessions; large or long-standing ones may need many, spaced four to six weeks apart. The dose and number are adjusted at each review to limit thinning of the surrounding skin.
Many soften, flatten and pale over 12 to 24 months, especially with silicone and time. Treatment is considered when a scar is itchy, painful, still thickening after several months or in a visible area. Keloids, by contrast, rarely settle on their own.
Injecting a firm keloid is uncomfortable for a few seconds per point. Numbing cream, fine needles and a slow technique reduce this. Silicone is not painful. Laser feels like brief heat or snapping. Any discomfort is discussed before treatment.
It is generally advised not to, because the same skin is likely to form another keloid. If you choose to, discuss it with a doctor first; some people use pressure earrings and early steroid at the first sign of thickening, but the risk remains.
On its own, rarely. Silicone is most useful for prevention and for early hypertrophic scars. On an established keloid it is mainly used alongside injections, or afterwards to help keep the scar flat.
Coverage depends on whether a treatment is considered medically necessary and on the scheme and insurer. Aesthetic treatments are generally not claimable. The clinic can explain what applies to you; see MediSave and insurance claims.
IN Eternity Clinic, 9 Scotts Road, #12-01 Pacific Plaza, Singapore 228210. By appointment with Medical Director Dr Sin Yong. Monday to Saturday, 11am to 8pm. WhatsApp or call +65 8815 3008. The consultation fee is waived with any medical treatment.
These sources describe mechanisms and general evidence. They are not a promise of any individual result; suitability is decided at an in-person assessment.